Choosing a belt bag, especially when it comes to travel, isn’t just about style—it’s about how it performs when you’re on the move. The Carhartt Water-Resistant Hip Pack and the Herschel Classic Hip Pack both promise hands-free convenience, but they serve different priorities. This side-by-side look breaks down design, durability, and real-world usability so you can quickly see which pack matches your travel routine.
Outdoor Adventures
The Carhartt Adjustable Waist Hip Pack offers ergonomic comfort and hands-free convenience for carrying your essentials on the go. Made from durable 600-denier polyester, it’s designed to withstand everyday wear and tear while remaining water-resistant.
On-the-Go
The Herschel Classic Hip Pack is made from 100% recycled materials, featuring a durable EcoSystem 600D fabric and a stylish tonal stripe liner. Its adjustable webbing strap and secure zippered closure provide a comfortable, hands-free carrying solution for your essentials.
Carhartt Water Resistant Hip Pack
Material
600-denier polyester for durability and water resistance
Dimensions
11.5 x 4.5 x 6 inches
Weight
7.2 ounces
Closure Type
Standard zip closure
Sustainability
Not considered a sustainable product
Herschel Classic Hip Pack
Material
EcoSystem 600D Fabric made from 100% recycled post-consumer water bottles
Dimensions
10.07 x 6.56 x 1.89 inches
Weight
5 ounces
Closure Type
Zippered closure with Prusik cord pull
Sustainability
Made from 100% recycled materials
Carhartt Water Resistant Hip Pack
Herschel Classic Hip Pack
Unique Strengths
Carhartt Adjustable Waist Hip Pack
- Built for rough use. Rugged fabric and heavy-duty zippers hold up to trail dust and daily wear.
- Weather-ready. Water-resistant coating shrugs off drizzle and splashes.
- Multi-purpose. Equally at home on hikes, work sites, or cross-country flights.
Herschel Supply Co. Classic Hip Pack
- City-smart style. Minimal design with a modern streetwear vibe.
- Festival-friendly. Compact, light, and easy to sling across the chest.
- Proven quality. Herschel’s stitching and hardware earn long-term fans.
Shared Features
Both packs adjust for a secure fit, include a front zip pocket for quick-grab items, and come in black plus seasonal colors.
Pros and Cons
Carhartt Adjustable Waist Hip Pack
Pros:
- Highly durable and functional.
- Water-resistant, great for outdoor use.
- More affordable price point.
Cons:
- May not appeal to those seeking a more fashionable look.
- Slightly bulkier compared to other options.
Herschel Supply Co. Classic Hip Pack
Pros:
- Stylish and trendy, ideal for daily casual wear.
- Lightweight and comfortable.
- High-quality material and craftsmanship.
Cons:
- Not water-resistant, less suited for rugged outdoor activities.
- Marginally higher price point.
Use-Cases
Carhartt Adjustable Waist Hip Pack
- Perfect for hiking trips, camping, and outdoor sports.
- Works well as a hands-free option for travel.
- Great for carrying tools or gear during construction work.
Herschel Supply Co. Classic Hip Pack
- Ideal for music festivals and casual outings.
- Good for everyday carry, including essentials like keys and phones.
- A fashionable choice for urban explorers.
Bottom Line
Choose Carhartt if you need a belt bag that can take rain, dirt, and heavy use. Pick Herschel if style and urban versatility matter more. Either way, you get a reliable, hands-free pack—just match it to how and where you travel.
